Communities Under Fear
- Jeremy Bratcher
- Jan 13
- 4 min read
ICE Overreach Isn’t Just a Policy Problem — It’s a Community Safety Crisis
A Necessary Clarification
Let me be clear: this is not an anti-law-enforcement argument. I work alongside police professionals. I serve in chaplaincy contexts that exist precisely because I believe in supporting those who carry the weight of public safety. This is also not a political statement disguised as concern. It is a community-health concern grounded in real conversations, real observations, and real consequences. My goal is not to attack officers or agencies, but to advocate for practices that preserve trust, protect citizens, and strengthen the safety of our neighborhoods. Accountability and community safety are not opposites — they are inseparable.
In recent conversations with police professionals here in Minnesota, one recurring theme has come up again and again: fear is keeping people from calling 911. Not just people without documentation — but legal residents, documented immigrants, and even U.S. citizens are hesitating to call for help during emergencies because they don’t know who’s responding and fear being caught up in federal immigration actions.
This isn’t conjecture. It’s what community safety officials are telling me directly about what they’re seeing on the ground.
What Local Police Are Actually Reporting
Police officers and community safety leaders have shared with me that:
Immigrant residents with valid documentation are afraid to be in public, afraid to interact with any law enforcement, and sometimes avoid essential services because they don’t know whether the person showing up is local police or a federal agent.
Some residents believe that any uniformed authority figure approaching them could be ICE — and that fear is discouraging 911 calls even when lives and property are at risk.
Several officers have described people asking neighbors for help instead of calling emergency services. Others have said they are spending increasing amounts of time simply trying to reassure residents that calling 911 is safe and appropriate — a role they shouldn’t have to play in a functioning public safety system.
The Economic Impact No One Is Talking About
I’ve also witnessed another layer of impact firsthand through my work in marketplace chaplaincy. Employees who are legally present in the United States — including citizens — have shared that they are afraid to go to work. Business owners have quietly admitted they’ve delayed opening or reduced hours because staff are afraid to leave their homes.
People are weighing the risk of earning a paycheck against the fear of being questioned, stopped, or caught in the wrong place at the wrong time. When fear disrupts livelihoods, it destabilizes families. When families destabilize, communities fracture.
At that point, this is no longer just an immigration issue. It becomes a workforce issue, a mental health issue, and a community resilience issue.
Why This Matters for Public Safety
If people are too afraid to call 911:
Crimes go unreported
Victims don’t seek help
Emergencies escalate
Police lose trust and cooperation from entire communities
Public safety is built on trust. Once that trust erodes, the entire system suffers — including the officers trying to do their jobs faithfully and the neighbors who depend on them.
Local departments are now also facing the added challenge of being confused with federal immigration enforcement, which further damages their ability to function as trusted community protectors. When people can’t distinguish between who is there to protect them and who they fear, the whole structure begins to collapse.
A Healthy, Legal, and Necessary Challenge
It is both possible and necessary to challenge this while respecting the rule of law.
We can:
Affirm that serious criminals should be the priority of any enforcement effort
Support law enforcement professionals who are trying to serve their communities with integrity
And still say clearly: broad, fear-based enforcement that destabilizes entire neighborhoods is not good policy and not good public safety
Good enforcement protects communities. Bad enforcement destabilizes them.
Reframing the Conversation
The public narrative often says enforcement is narrowly focused on the worst offenders. But what police professionals, business leaders, and community members are reporting locally tells a more complicated story.
When citizens are afraid to call 911.When employees are afraid to go to work. When business owners hesitate to open their doors. When neighbors avoid public spaces.
That’s not effective public safety. That’s social breakdown.
We should be able to ask hard questions about tactics, oversight, and accountability without being labeled anti-law-enforcement or anti-safety. In fact, raising these concerns is one of the most pro-community and pro-safety things we can do.
Public safety requires trust, clarity, and accountability — not fear.
Helpful Resources for Immigrant Families and Concerned Community Members
Know Your Rights – ACLU
Clear guidance on what to do if stopped by law enforcement or immigration officers.
https://www.aclu.org/know-your-rights/immigrants-rights
Immigrant Legal Resource Center (ILRC)
Practical toolkits for families, workers, and communities.
https://www.ilrc.org/resources
United We Dream – Community Support & Resources
Mental health resources, emergency planning guides, and family preparedness.
https://unitedwedream.org/resources/
National Immigration Law Center (NILC)
Legal guidance and current policy explanations.
https://www.nilc.org/issues/immigration-enforcement/
Local Legal Aid (Minnesota example if you want to localize it):
Mid-Minnesota Legal Aid
The Advocates for Human Rights (Minnesota-based, widely respected)
https://www.theadvocatesforhumanrights.org
If someone is in immediate danger:
Call 911. Local emergency services exist to protect life and safety. Many police departments continue to affirm that they do not ask about immigration status when responding to emergency calls.
Comments